The Presidency has deleted a controversial photograph shared by President Bola Tinubu’s media aide, Dada Olusegun, that appeared to show a large crowd at the All Progressives Congress (APC) North-Central rally in Jos, Plateau State, after allegations that the image was manipulated using artificial intelligence (AI).
The photograph, posted on Olusegun’s X account on Sunday, November 15, carried the caption, “Plateau State for PBAT”. It appeared to show a densely packed stadium during the rally Tinubu attended the previous day.
However, the image attracted criticism after social media users questioned whether it accurately represented the turnout at the event. Some users shared other photographs and video recordings from the rally, arguing that they showed considerably fewer people in parts of the venue.
The controversy gained further attention on Monday, November 16, after the Foundation for Investigative Journalism (FIJ) published an investigation into the photograph, reporting evidence of AI involvement in its creation or alteration.
According to FIJ, its examination using Google SynthID and Image Whisperer produced indications that the photograph had been generated or digitally modified using AI technology.
Google SynthID returned the message, “This media was made or edited with OpenAI,” indicating a provenance signal associated with OpenAI-generated content.
FIJ also reported that two of the four principal detection tools used through Image Whisperer identified the photograph as potentially AI-generated or manipulated. The tools returned scores of 98 and 99, respectively, while the other two did not support the same conclusion.
The investigation further identified apparent inconsistencies in the photograph, including the images of Tinubu and Vice President Kashim Shettima displayed on a stadium banner.
However, FIJ cautioned that the findings did not establish whether the entire photograph was generated using AI or whether an original image was later altered.
The rally itself took place at Zaria Road Stadium in Jos on Saturday, November 14. Tinubu attended the APC North-Central political gathering, where he addressed supporters and spoke about issues affecting Plateau State.
The dispute centres on the authenticity of the photograph and whether it accurately represented the crowd at the event.
The deletion of the image followed the public criticism, although no official explanation for its removal had been provided in the reports available as of Tuesday, November 17.
Neither the Presidency nor Olusegun had publicly clarified the circumstances surrounding the photograph’s creation, publication and subsequent removal in the reports reviewed.
Related:
- Nigeria Expands Use of AI in Security and Surveillance
- If the Presidency Can Be Deepfaked, None of Us Is Safe
The incident has renewed concerns about the use of AI-generated and digitally altered images in political communication, particularly as political parties intensify activities ahead of Nigeria’s 2027 general elections.
It has also highlighted the importance of verifying photographs shared through official government and political communication channels, given their potential to influence public perception.
While AI tools can be used for legitimate image enhancement and content production, presenting digitally altered material as an authentic record of a public event without appropriate disclosure can undermine public confidence.
The Presidency’s response to the controversy, including clarification of how the photograph was produced and why it was deleted, remains outstanding. INEC News
